# Systematic Scoping and Critical Review | Research manuscript template

> TEMPLATE ONLY — not a completed research paper, a deposited preprint or a claim of new findings.

**Working title:** [Specific and defensible]

**Manuscript status:** Research initiative / draft / submitted / accepted / published [choose accurately]

**Version and date:** [YYYY-MM-DD, v0.1]

**Target venue:** [Select after reviewing the current official author guidelines]

**Authors and contributions:** [Use authorised, accurate attribution]

## Proposed abstract

[State the research problem, objective, intended method and anticipated contribution. Do not invent findings or claim experimental results that do not yet exist. Replace this with a results-based abstract only after analysis.]

**Keywords:** [5–8 precise terms]

## 1. Review objective and questions

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 2. Background and prior reviews

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 3. Search strategy, databases and search dates

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 4. Eligibility, screening and selection flow

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 5. Extraction and evidence appraisal

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 6. Synthesis and disagreement mapping

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 7. Evidence gaps and review limitations

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## 8. Implications and updates to the review

[Write specific, source-grounded content. Distinguish verified observations, provisional interpretations, methodological plans and missing evidence.]

## References

[Add verified bibliographic records, primary sources, DOIs and publication details; do not invent citations.]

## Research integrity and claims-to-evidence register

| Claim / research question | Supporting source or experiment | Status | Uncertainty / omission | Verification action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Claim or question] | [Source URL / dataset / script] | Proposed | [Known limitation] | [Next check] |

## Reproducibility and supporting artifacts

- Code repository: [Insert verified GitHub URL if a coding project exists; otherwise 'Not yet created' or 'Not applicable']
- Archived research artifact: [Insert verified Zenodo record DOI only after deposition]
- Data access and permissions: [Licensing, ethical approval, privacy constraints]
- Computational environment: [Software, hardware, versions, random seeds where relevant]
- Independent verification: [Reviewer or test protocol]

## Publication readiness

[Verify the target venue's official template and current requirements: formatting, anonymisation, ethics, limitations, citations, accessibility, open materials and AI-tool disclosures.]

## Version and corrections

| Date | Version | Substantive change | Supporting evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| [YYYY-MM-DD] | v0.1 | Template initiated | [Source] |
