Manifold Grace
RESEARCH & KNOWLEDGE · COMPARATIVE FRAMEWORKS

National & Global Frameworks Completeness Atlas

Beyond PESTLE: compare the different truths captured by national, global, institutional, social, economic and ecological frameworks—and identify where broader integrative approaches could add value.

OPEN RESEARCH INVENTORY · 9 NOVEMBER 2026

What completeness can—and cannot—mean

This initial index contains 33 distinct frameworks, families or indices, grouped by their primary purpose. It is a curated starting inventory, not a claim that every framework in the world has been enumerated. Some are formal indices with published indicators; others are strategy tools or research models. Their names must not be treated as equivalent measurements.

A framework can be complete for its stated question while deliberately omitting other subjects. Consequently, the third column records illustrative scope limitations relative to an all-society ambition, not proven design defects. Formal comprehensiveness audits must inspect full methodology, indicator lists, data availability and actual practice before grading.

Research method: retain every framework's primary source, version, definition, unit of analysis, jurisdictions, time coverage, measurable dimensions, exclusions, contested assumptions, longitudinal comparability and correction history. Update this register as additional frameworks are discovered.

Macroenvironment

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
PESTLEPolitical, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental driversContext scan, not outcomes or causal proof
STEEP / STEEPLESocial, technological, economic, environmental, political; variants add legal and ethical factorsCategories vary; little direct measurement
SWOTInternal strengths and weaknesses; external opportunities and threatsSubjective positioning rather than national metrics
Scenario planningPlausible alternative futures and uncertaintiesNot a comprehensive state-of-society index

Global development

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
UN Sustainable Development Goals17 goals, 169 targets spanning development and sustainabilityWide normative agenda; indicator gaps and attribution challenges
OECD Well-being Framework11 current wellbeing dimensions and four future-capital resourcesStrong quality-of-life scope; less focused on causal institutional chains
Human Development Index (HDI)Health, education and incomeDeliberately simplified; limited environment and institutional detail
Inequality-adjusted HDIHDI adjusted for within-country inequalityStill draws on HDI dimensions rather than all societal conditions
Multidimensional Poverty IndexHousehold deprivations across health, education and living standardsPoverty-focused; not a full development model
Planetary pressures-adjusted HDIHuman development discounted for selected planetary pressuresDoes not measure every ecological or social issue
Social Progress IndexSocial and environmental outcomes beyond traditional economic metricsNot a complete causal or fiscal institutional model
World Happiness ReportPopulation life evaluations and related explanatory factorsNot equivalent to all forms of meaning, justice or opportunity
Genuine Progress IndicatorEconomic welfare adjustments for social and environmental costsAccounting choices vary by implementation

Sustainability

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
Doughnut EconomicsSocial foundation paired with planetary ecological ceilingStrong integrative sustainability lens; implementation depends on local data
Planetary BoundariesNine Earth-system processes defining ecological risk boundariesNot a comprehensive human development assessment
Ecological FootprintBiologically productive resource demand relative to biocapacityNot a substitute for all biodiversity or social metrics
Sendai FrameworkDisaster-risk reduction priorities and targetsFocused on hazards and resilience, not total societal wellbeing

Governance & rights

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
Worldwide Governance IndicatorsSix governance dimensions, including accountability, effectiveness and rule of lawAggregated perception measures; not precise institutional diagnoses
World Justice Project Rule of Law IndexEight factors from constraints on government to criminal and civil justiceRule-of-law-specific; does not cover full socioeconomic development
Freedom in the WorldPolitical rights and civil libertiesDoes not measure overall living standards or infrastructure
Corruption Perceptions IndexPerceived public-sector corruptionPerception-based and narrowly corruption-focused
Fragile States IndexStructural pressures and vulnerabilities affecting statesEmphasises fragility and risk rather than all positive capabilities
Global Peace IndexPeacefulness, societal safety, conflict and militarisation dimensionsDoes not comprehensively cover economic mobility or education quality

Economy & enterprise

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
World Bank B-READYRegulatory framework, public services and operational efficiency for firmsFirm environment focus; not full citizen wellbeing
Logistics Performance Indicators 2.0Supply-chain connection and time indicators across transport modesTrade logistics only; no overall national quality-of-life score
ILO Decent Work AgendaEmployment, rights at work, social protection and social dialogueLabour-focused rather than a general societal theory
Global Competitiveness frameworkProductivity-related institutions, markets, infrastructure and skillsEconomic performance focus; methodology differs by edition

Inequality & participation

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
Global Gender Gap IndexGender parity in economy, education, health and politicsParity measures do not alone establish absolute living conditions
Gender Inequality IndexReproductive health, empowerment and labour-market inequalityFocused on selected gender inequality outcomes
Social mobility indicatorsOccupational, income, education and housing trajectories between generationsRequires granular and longitudinal data; varies by country

Risk & technology

Framework and sourceWhat it coversLimits for a whole-society assessment
WEF Global Risks ReportInterconnected global risks over near, medium and long horizonsExpert-perception risk lens, not a complete success index
NIST AI Risk Management FrameworkGoverning, mapping, measuring and managing AI riskTechnology-specific and voluntary; not full national governance
UNESCO AI Ethics RecommendationHuman rights, inclusion, governance and ethical AI deploymentAI focus, not exhaustive social assessment

Proposed twelve-axis completeness audit

Evaluate each framework against the following researcher-proposed axes: human health and wellbeing; material security and housing; relationships and culture; education and capability; work, enterprise and financial mobility; rights and justice; governance and delivery; infrastructure and technology; ecology and resource stewardship; international interdependence; shocks and resilience; longitudinal continuity, implementation and accountability.

For each axis record: 0 not addressed, 1 acknowledged, 2 partially measured, 3 robustly operationalised, N/A outside design scope, ? not yet verified. These are provisional coding categories, not validated psychometric scores. Record explicit definitions, evidence links, uncertainty and reviewer disagreements before comparing frameworks. Missingness, double-counting and opposing effects must be visible.

Further audit lenses should include: person/household/community/institution/nation/world; current versus future; outcomes versus explanatory drivers; cross-domain interactions and second-order effects; state versus non-state action; distribution by affected population; rights versus discretionary preferences; and when non-aggregation is ethically necessary.

Potential original integrative frameworks

These acronyms are provisional labels; neither their uniqueness nor their completeness has been established. Prior-art searching must include academic repositories, policy literature, commercial usage and older terminology before any claim of originality.

Design principle: A universal-looking acronym will not itself 'cover everything'. A more credible research contribution may be a modular ontology and cross-framework evidence graph that can expand as new domains, institutions and values emerge, while showing unmeasured dimensions and conflicting assumptions.

Working-paper initiative

Provisional title: Beyond PESTLE: Mapping the Coverage, Omissions and Interdependencies of National and Global Assessment Frameworks.

Planned study: systematic framework discovery; eligibility and coding protocol; official methodology extraction; twelve-axis coverage matrix; overlap and contradiction analysis; sensitivity testing; stakeholder review; comparison of non-additive outcomes; and case studies contrasting apparent progress with lived conditions.

Research status: indexed literature and conceptual study design only. There is no completed systematic review, novel validated metric or published working-paper manuscript at this stage.

Related research

MILES Research Architecture · Interdisciplinary Atlas · Government & Society · Designing Fairer Systems · Education, Learning & Development · Research.

Initial curated atlas · 9 November 2026 · Expanded comparison and validation required before conclusions about exhaustive coverage.