RESEARCH & KNOWLEDGE · INTEGRATED SOCIETAL INTELLIGENCE
Public Authority, Integrity Gaps & AI-Assisted Reporting
Research framework for comparing the rules institutions publish with evidence of how those rules operate. The central proposed AI application is to help researchers and members of the public assemble, verify and report substantiated discrepancies—not to label people as corrupt.
Migration, fair treatment & cooperation paper initiative · Government directory · Public systems research · Dated activity record
Statistical basis and limits
Primary evidence: OECD Anti-Corruption and Integrity Outlook 2026, Chapter 4 and National Audit Office overview of fraud and error in 2023–24. The OECD gap is a multi-country average; it cannot be assumed to represent the UK specifically. The NAO estimate includes fraud and error, not merely deliberate wrongdoing.
Evidence standard: A role, social connection, donation, apparent generosity, disagreement with government or statistical anomaly is not evidence of misconduct. The AI must record uncertainty, seek alternative explanations, avoid profiling protected groups and require human verification before external reporting.
Roles and records to examine
| Institutional setting | Discretionary roles | Evidence sources | Independent checks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Central government | Ministers, accounting officers, senior officials | Official responsibilities, spending, declarations, published decisions | National Audit Office; Parliament; departmental governance |
| Agencies and regulators | Directors, boards, case decision-makers | Appointments, registers, enforcement records, annual reports | Relevant statutory appeals, oversight and audit functions |
| Local authorities | Councillors, officers, planning and procurement decision-makers | Interest registers, planning decisions, contracts, audits | Monitoring officers, standards processes, external audit |
| Public services | Commissioners, delegated managers | Case criteria, complaints, service and purchasing outcomes | Sector regulators, inspectorates and ombudsmen |
| Private suppliers | Directors, beneficial owners, contract counterparties | Contract notices, ownership, related-party disclosures | Procurement authorities and appropriate regulators |
Official directories: UK government organisations; ministers; Companies House; Contracts Finder. Any examination should use officeholders and rules applicable at the date of the decision.
Proposed AI evidence-to-reporting workflow
| Stage | AI assistance | Required safeguard |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Capture obligations | Extract statutory duties, policies, eligibility rules and effective dates | Quote and link to authoritative primary documents |
| 2. Capture implementation | Organise dated public records, audit findings and comparable decisions | Preserve provenance, omissions and confidence limits |
| 3. Gap detection | Compare obligations against documented procedures or outcomes; flag missing declarations and inconsistent decisions | A flag means review needed, never guilt |
| 4. Statistical testing | Compute rates, baselines, disparities, uncertainty intervals and sensitivity checks | Control for case mix, selection effects and missing data |
| 5. Contradiction testing | Identify documents that weaken or contradict an initial hypothesis | Require alternative explanations and falsification attempts |
| 6. Reporting | Generate factual, source-linked summaries for the appropriate oversight channel | Human approval, privacy screening, neutral language and appeal/correction procedures |
| 7. Follow-up | Track responses, corrections and outcomes over time | Versioned logs; no automated public accusations |
The AI component is a proposed design, not a trained or deployed system. Its first evaluation should use synthetic or anonymised cases with known ground truth, measuring extraction precision, false-positive rates, evidence coverage, reviewer agreement, fairness and correction handling. Model training should not use unverified accusations as factual labels.
Relevant safeguards: UK Algorithmic Transparency Recording Standard; UK Data and AI Ethics Framework; NAO: Using data analytics to tackle fraud and error.
Falsifiable research questions
H1 — Are declarations and oversight requirements actually fulfilled?
Measure the proportion of required declarations submitted, verified and addressed against applicable requirements; test whether missingness arises from data availability or actual non-compliance.
H2 — Are comparable discretionary decisions treated consistently?
Compare similarly situated cases after adjusting for relevant lawful factors and documented reasons; examine counterexamples and decisions inconsistent with the hypothesis.
H3 — Do documented interests predict decision outcomes?
Use verified and legally relevant affiliations only; test with controls, robustness checks and independently reviewed case records. Association is not automatically causation.
H4 — Do subsequent donations correlate with influence or restitution?
Compare timing, recipient organisations, documented benefits and measurable remedies; avoid inferring intention from philanthropy alone.
H5 — Do private bodies exercise authority outside lawful mandates?
Evaluate specific rule-making and enforcement against legal delegation, consent and jurisdiction; distinguish lawful civil society activity from coercive unlawful conduct.
Research and implementation status
Evidence source review and research design documented: 11 November 2026. The figures above are aggregate context, not results from original case-level tests. No allegation register has been populated, no live reporting endpoint has been built and no machine-learning model has been trained. Further validation must be documented before interpreting any individual institutional case.